1.6 Small Group · Group 2
Tier 1 Extension · Non-Routine Synthesis · Misconception Traps · Rigorous CER Proofs
make sense of a problem · representation · Procedural Fluency · Real-World Applications
- You already can do this. So we go up a level, not up a number: find what is always true, show it a second way, and be ready to defend it with a reason instead of an answer.
- First I make sense of it: one rack holds 8 bikes, each bike has 2 wheels, so this rack has 8 × 2 = 16 wheels. The other rack has 6 times as many wheels — that is what I don't know yet.
- I choose a representation: 6 equal groups of 16. Then I make a plan: multiply.
- 16 × 6 = 96, so the other rack has about 96 wheels. I check my progress: 96 is 6 groups of 16, and 16 × 6 = 96, so my answer matches my plan.
- When we do math, sometimes we get stuck. What can we try?
- Think of questions to ask a classmate or the teacher. Visualize the problem or draw pictures of it.
- Think of problems we have seen like this before. Identify what we don't understand about the problem.
- Which of these have you actually used? Which will you try next time?
- Now prove it: say why that move had to work at all — not just that it did.
- Sentence frame — convince a skeptic: "My method works because ___ . It would stop working if ___ ."
- make sense of a problem (comprender un problema) — To figure out what a problem is asking — what you know, and what you don't know yet.
- representation (representación) — A way of showing a problem — a drawing, table, equation, or model — that helps you see it.
- strategy (estrategia) — A plan of attack for a problem — and something you can switch when you get stuck.
- critique (criticar constructivamente) — To examine an idea and say what is convincing or not — about the idea, never about the person.
- community agreement (acuerdo comunitario) — A rule the whole class agrees to so that everyone can learn together.
- Treating 'stuck' as a stop sign instead of a signal — waiting silently instead of trying a strategy: asking a question, drawing the problem, or recalling a similar problem.
-
1 FILL TABLE
Use the bicycle rack problem to complete the table.
Question Thinking Answer Wheels on a rack of 8 bikes Wheels on the bigger rack (6 times as many) Bikes on the bigger rack ✏️ Scratchpad / Reasoning -
2 MATCHING GAME
Match each stuck moment to the strategy that gets you unstuck.
- My strategy is not making progress
- I don't understand the problem
- My answer looks unreasonable
- My partner got a different answer
- ATry a different entry point
- BRestate it in your own words
- CCheck it against an estimate
- DCompare steps and find where they differ
-
3 MULTIPLE CHOICE
Priya tries to answer 'how many bikes fit 96 wheels?' by drawing every single wheel. After two minutes she has 30 wheels drawn and is losing track. By this lesson's process, what should she do?
- ANotice the strategy is not making progress and shift — her drawing already shows every 2 wheels is a bike, so compute 96 ÷ 2
- BKeep drawing: quitting a strategy means the strategy failed
- CErase everything and start guessing numbers
- DDecide the problem is unsolvable and move on
✏️ Workspace & Solution Steps -
4 MULTIPLE CHOICE
You are working on your own and get stuck. Which move follows BOTH parts of our working-alone agreements?
- ATry a get-unstuck strategy first, then quietly ask for help without interrupting classmates unnecessarily
- BImmediately call across the room to a friend
- CSit silently for the rest of class without seeking help
- DTake a classmate's paper to see their work
✏️ Workspace & Solution Steps
-
5 OPEN RESPONSE
Write your own 'times as many' problem about our school that a classmate could solve, and build in the trap from this lesson (a reader might add instead of multiply). Then give the correct answer AND the trap answer, with a sentence telling them apart.
✏️ Mathematical Justification & Response -
6 OPEN RESPONSE
A classmate claims: 'Group work slows me down — I solve faster alone.' Using the rack problem, write a respectful response that names ONE specific mathematical thing a partner caught or contributed that solo work would likely miss.
✏️ Mathematical Justification & Response
Complete each sentence stem to demonstrate precise mathematical reasoning:
Writing Task: Justify why your mathematical solution is accurate and complete.