4.5 Small Group · Group 2
Tier 1 Extension · Non-Routine Synthesis · Misconception Traps · Rigorous CER Proofs
Visual Models · Determine the Whole Given the Part and Percent · Part · Procedural Fluency
- You already can do this. So we go up a level, not up a number: find what is always true, show it a second way, and be ready to defend it with a reason instead of an answer.
- Akela paid $42 for a sweater on sale, and that was 60% of the original price. The $42 is the part; the original price is the whole, which is 100%.
- On a double number line, I put $42 under 60%. To find a smaller step, I use 10%: if 60% is $42, then 10% is 42 ÷ 6 = $7.
- Now I count up to the whole: 100% is ten of those 10% steps, so 10 × $7 = $70.
- The equation says the same thing in one move: 0.6 × v = 42, so v = 42 ÷ 0.6 = 70. The original price was $70 — larger than the sale price, which is exactly what a discount should mean.
- Sheng's car is now worth $26,600, which is 70% of what his parents paid for it. Find the original price.
- Name the pieces first: $26,600 is the part, 70% is the percent, and the purchase price is the unknown whole.
- Write the percentage statement as an equation, using the decimal form: 0.7v = 26,600.
- Solve by dividing both sides by 0.7: v = 26,600 ÷ 0.7 = 38,000. The car cost $38,000 when they bought it.
- Now prove it: say why that move had to work at all — not just that it did.
- Sentence frame — convince a skeptic: "My method works because ___ . It would stop working if ___ ."
- Determine the Whole Given the Part and Percent (Hallar el total dados la parte y el porcentaje) — Working backwards from a part and its percent to find the whole amount it came from.
- Part (Parte) — The amount you already know — the piece of the whole that the percent describes.
- Whole (Total) — The full amount the percent is measured against. The whole is always 100%.
- Double number line (Recta numérica doble) — Two lines lined up — dollars on one, percents on the other — so matching marks show the same amount two ways.
- Equation (Ecuación) — A math sentence with an equal sign. Here it says percent × whole = part, with the whole unknown.
- Percent (Porcentaje) — A ratio comparing a number to 100. To compute with it, write it in decimal form: 60% = 0.6.
- A common mistake when finding the whole is multiplying by the percent instead of dividing. For "$42 is 60% of the original price," computing 0.6 × 42 = $25.20 makes the original price SMALLER than the sale price — impossible for a discount. Since percent × whole = part, the whole is found by dividing: 42 ÷ 0.6 = $70. Whenever the percent is less than 100%, the whole must come out larger than the part, so a smaller answer is the tell.
-
1 FILL TABLE
$42 is 60% of the original price. Complete the ratio table to reach 100%.
Percent Dollars 60% 10% 100% ✏️ Scratchpad / Reasoning -
2 BAR MODEL
A sweater's sale price of $42 is 60% of the original price. Each section is 10%. Use the bar model to find the original price.
✏️ Workspace & Solution Steps
-
3 MULTIPLE CHOICE
A shop reports that this week's $60 in sales is 120% of last week's. Was last week better or worse, and by how much?
- AWorse — last week was $50, so sales rose by $10
- BBetter — last week was $72, so sales fell
- CWorse — last week was $48
- DYou cannot tell without knowing the number of items sold
✏️ Workspace & Solution Steps -
4 MULTIPLE CHOICE
To find the whole when $9 is 25% of it, Lena divides 9 by 0.25. Omar reasons that 25% is a quarter, so he multiplies 9 by 4. Whose method works?
- ABoth — dividing by 0.25 and multiplying by 4 are the same operation
- BOnly Lena — multiplying cannot undo a percent
- COnly Omar — you should never divide by a decimal
- DNeither — you need the whole before you can use either method
✏️ Workspace & Solution Steps -
5 MULTIPLE CHOICE
To find the whole from a part and a percent, you…
- ADivide the part by the percent in decimal form
- BMultiply the part by the percent
- CAdd the part and the percent
- DSubtract the percent from 100
✏️ Workspace & Solution Steps -
6 MULTIPLE CHOICE
Claim: “If the percent is less than 100, the whole is always bigger than the part.” Always, sometimes, or never true?
- AAlways — a percent under 100 describes less than one whole, so the whole must be larger
- BSometimes — it depends whether the numbers are money or counts
- CNever — the part and the whole are always equal
- DSometimes — it fails when the percent is under 10
✏️ Workspace & Solution Steps
Group Discussion Prompt: How does your visual model justify your mathematical solution?
Partner A: "I modeled this by identifying the relationship and..."
Partner B: "I agree with your step because the standard mathematical rule states..."
Complete each sentence stem to demonstrate precise mathematical reasoning:
Writing Task: Justify why your mathematical solution is accurate and complete.